My previous post discussed how mistaken thinking about research evidence in nutrition has led to a misleading or even false understanding of how we should approach and maintain our health. A broader question than the argument-from-uncertainty fallacy arises: what is it in the nature of scientific investigation that makes these kinds of errors possible? The short answer is that there is no free market in science that would facilitate the quick awareness of both innovation and error. What we have today is government domination of research that deflects attention away from concern for the constituents the science is intended to serve, for example, doctors and their patients in medicine, to compliance with the rules of grantsmanship and peer review the ultimate aim of which is publication for tenure and promotion in the cloistered academic world.*
Though data fabrication and other frauds do occur, the most important cause of flawed research is the “what do we have to do to get the money and then the publication” attitude. This expedient in the protected environment of academia leads to conventional, uninspired, and sometimes substandard, politically biased, and irrelevant work, much of it amounting to useless minutia. I don’t mean to imply that there is a willful disregard for truth or facts on the part of researchers, though again that sometimes does occur, but that the system in which academics compete for money and accolades predisposes them to pursue conventional lines of inquiry.
“The problem in science,” states the chief medical officer of the American Cancer Society, “is that the way you get ahead is by staying within narrow parameters and doing what other people are doing. No one wants to fund wild new ideas.” Except profit-making private companies like Revlon. And peer review does not encourage originality or novelty. As British medical researcher David Horrobin pointed out in 1995, the acceptance of eighteen medical innovations was either delayed or thwarted by the process. The system is also notorious for not publishing findings that are negative, that is, studies that do not produce significant findings, on the alleged assumption that what works is more important and interesting than what does not.
In my 2007 posts (1, 2) on peer review I argued that fear of the new governs and that the process is no guarantee of objectivity. This last has been demonstrated by studies retrospectively analyzing the results of published work. How so? “Miscalculation, poor study design or self-serving data analysis,” in the words of Wall Street Journal science writer Robert Lee Hotz. The pressures of publication cause sloppiness and cherry picking of the data—data mining or data massaging, as researchers call it, to find something publishable. (Selection bias was the term used in last month’s post.) All of this then brings about a recurrent lack of replication of the original study. Failure to replicate puts the science back to square one. Often it is the private, profit-making companies, using the double-blind research technique, who cannot replicate the work of the academics, because academics frequently fail to double-blind their experiments.
Horrobin’s solution to the screening and gatekeeping process of peer review was to divide the research money equally among researchers, then let the researchers be guided by their own interests in choosing what to study. This would remove the rule-bound, paper pushing requirements of the bureaucracy and free scientists to do what they do best, namely research. Horrobin pointed out that research money was distributed in precisely this way prior to 1960 in Great Britain and resulted in more medical innovations then than since. Of course, the grant money Horrobin was talking about was from the government. Remove government involvement in research and let more retained earnings of profit-making businesses be made available and you will see more responsiveness to the market, that is, to the consumers of the research.
Bureaucrats—anyone who works for or is excessively regulated by the government, including college professors who are most of the researchers I am talking about—answer only to the requirements of the bureaucracy. Profit-making businesses, on the other hand, have a huge incentive to innovate, to increase their profits; if they make mistakes, they pay dearly, and not just in lost sales or return on investment. The bureaucrat’s response to anyone who complains about the conventionality or mistakes of present-day research is to say, “I just follow the rules. We have a process to follow if the rules need to be changed. It may take time, but that’s the way it is.”
Entrepreneurial innovators and innovative researchers don’t hesitate to go outside the conventional box, which means they don’t follow rules. Their attitude is, “What can we do to push back the frontiers of business or science?” To do that, they break rules.
*Two-thirds of the roughly $58 billion spent each year on research in universities is financed by the federal, state, and local governments, 59% by the US government alone.
This blog comments on business, education, philosophy, psychology, and economics, among other topics, based on my understanding of Ayn Rand’s philosophy, Ludwig von Mises’ economics, and Edith Packer's psychology. Epistemology and psychology are my special interests. Note that I assume ethical egoism and laissez-faire capitalism are morally and economically unassailable. My interest is in applying, not defending, them.
Showing posts with label argument from uncertainty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label argument from uncertainty. Show all posts
Friday, January 20, 2012
Saturday, December 03, 2011
Nutrition and the Argument from Uncertainty
The fallacy of the argument from uncertainty, or at least one form of it, might also be called the “it’s better to be safe than sorry” argument. For example, the European Union among other inanities recently ruled that children under eight must be supervised while blowing up a balloon, lest the children swallow or choke on part or all of the dangerous inflatable. How likely is this to occur? “Well, we don’t really know for sure,” the reasoning apparently goes. “We can’t be certain, so it’s better to be safe than sorry. An adult must be present.”
The problem with this reasoning is that it is asking opponents to prove a negative. “The balloon might cause choking. Prove that it won’t.” In logic proving a negative cannot be done; the burden of proof is on the one who makes the positive assertion. All that can be said accurately here is that the probability of choking is minuscule and parents must choose their own levels of risk tolerance. When pressure groups and their legislators tell us what to do, our freedoms and possibly our health become endangered.
This last is meticulously demonstrated in the exhaustive investigations of science writer Gary Taubes. In his two latest books, Good Calories, Bad Calories and Why We Get Fat, Taubes reviews over one hundred years of research on the causes of several diseases of civilization, especially heart disease, obesity, and diabetes. His finding is that not only is the consensus of the past thirty to forty years wrong, but that it also was generated and is today still maintained by the argument from uncertainty (my terminology, not his).
The litany of contemporary nutrition says that we should eat a high carbohydrate, low fat—low saturated fat—diet in order to maintain our heart health, remain trim, and fend off diabetes. If overweight, we should of course exercise and cut back on the calories. Taubes found little sound evidence in the scientific literature to support these claims and indeed uncovered a wisdom that was conventional for over a hundred years, until after World War II, that said good health, including trim weight, is achieved by eating a low carbohydrate, high meat, fish, and fowl diet. That is, cut out the sugars and starches and eat as much of the rest as you want. Exercise? It makes us hungry, something from the foggy distant past that our mothers and grandmothers used to say; it does not cause weight loss. Cholesterol and saturated fat? No causal relation to heart disease. Go low carb for all three diseases.
What gives? Are today’s nutritionists lying? No, just “better to be safe than sorry,” so they seem to be saying. During the 1950s and ‘60s, the more rigorous scientific researchers said that data on fat and cholesterol in relation to heart disease were inconclusive, in particular the data of the Seven Countries Study, a project notably omitting France and other countries that would have contradicted the study’s findings. This study, the rigorous researchers said, was at most associational, not causal.
The promoters of the Seven Countries Study, however, said that lives were at stake. We can’t wait for “final scientific proof” (Taubes, p. 23). We must inform the public and have them change their diets. This attitude partnered with the ‘60s hostility to McDonalds and other high-fat fast food diets and culminated in the McGovern report of 1977 that made the litany virtually gospel. In the meantime, well-controlled experiments, right up to the present, continued and still continue to disconfirm the creed. Selection bias, the omission of anomalous data, is a term Taubes uses to help explain the championing of the litany.
In the course of his investigations, Taubes most importantly has liberated obese people from the tyranny of the “gluttony and sloth” argument. “You’re overweight because you eat too much and exercise too little.” Implication? Weakness of the will, bad character. Taubes and the more rigorous researchers? Clearly there is a genetic component to growing wide, just as there is a genetic component to growing tall. Causation indeed likely runs in the opposite direction. That is, we are not necessarily fat because we overeat and underexercise. Rather, we eat more because we are growing and become sedentary because we are fat.
The mechanism of obesity, writes Taubes (pp. 118-21), operates through the hormone insulin. The more carbohydrates we eat, the more insulin our bodies secrete, the more fat—for obese people, at any rate—is taken out of our bloodstream and stored in our fat cells. “Insulin,” as Taubes puts it, “works to make us fatter.”
Coercion in the public schools to make children eat “right” or less has become common, just as the European Union is now making sure children are not unduly exposed to those allegedly dangerous inflatables. Aside from the issue that governments have no right to tell us what or how much to eat, or how we should micromanage our children, how fallacy-proof is the scientific evidence that has led to these policies and near dogma about health and safety? How long before we’re all compelled to eat “right” or less?
Taubes has shown us how bad science can become a new consensus and lead to policy. I hope my attempt to condense his seven hundred pages into a few paragraphs is clear and correct. Why We Get Fat is only two hundred pages. I enthusiastically recommend that you read it. Taubes’ writing is sparklingly clear. His website is garytaubes.com.
This now completes five years of blogging. January 2012 begins the next five. Here are a couple of follow-ups on previous posts.
On Hitting . . . Dogs and Children. “With the popularity of The Dog Whisperer television show, books and products, the controversy over which methods are the most humane and effective ways to address behavior problems in dogs is dividing dog lovers all over the world.
“While animal behaviorists, trainers and other dog professionals recognize that the show is exposing dog owners to the possibility that their dogs’ behavior can be changed (and indeed, business is booming), the concern is that the show gives the false impression that behavior can be changed within a matter of hours and that the methods used are known to incite or increase aggressive behaviors.” Read more (1, 2).
Should Spanking Be a Felony? “Is it right or wrong to spank? It is not a question of right or wrong; in a way it is a case of cowardliness, for you are hitting someone not your own size. I don’t suppose you hit your husband when he is being a nuisance. Is it because you wouldn’t dare? He might strike you back. Of course, you’re perfectly safe hitting your child of three. She can’t strike you back.
“Spanking is an outlet for adult rage and frustration and hate. . . . Happy mothers do not spank . . .”
The problem with this reasoning is that it is asking opponents to prove a negative. “The balloon might cause choking. Prove that it won’t.” In logic proving a negative cannot be done; the burden of proof is on the one who makes the positive assertion. All that can be said accurately here is that the probability of choking is minuscule and parents must choose their own levels of risk tolerance. When pressure groups and their legislators tell us what to do, our freedoms and possibly our health become endangered.
This last is meticulously demonstrated in the exhaustive investigations of science writer Gary Taubes. In his two latest books, Good Calories, Bad Calories and Why We Get Fat, Taubes reviews over one hundred years of research on the causes of several diseases of civilization, especially heart disease, obesity, and diabetes. His finding is that not only is the consensus of the past thirty to forty years wrong, but that it also was generated and is today still maintained by the argument from uncertainty (my terminology, not his).
The litany of contemporary nutrition says that we should eat a high carbohydrate, low fat—low saturated fat—diet in order to maintain our heart health, remain trim, and fend off diabetes. If overweight, we should of course exercise and cut back on the calories. Taubes found little sound evidence in the scientific literature to support these claims and indeed uncovered a wisdom that was conventional for over a hundred years, until after World War II, that said good health, including trim weight, is achieved by eating a low carbohydrate, high meat, fish, and fowl diet. That is, cut out the sugars and starches and eat as much of the rest as you want. Exercise? It makes us hungry, something from the foggy distant past that our mothers and grandmothers used to say; it does not cause weight loss. Cholesterol and saturated fat? No causal relation to heart disease. Go low carb for all three diseases.
What gives? Are today’s nutritionists lying? No, just “better to be safe than sorry,” so they seem to be saying. During the 1950s and ‘60s, the more rigorous scientific researchers said that data on fat and cholesterol in relation to heart disease were inconclusive, in particular the data of the Seven Countries Study, a project notably omitting France and other countries that would have contradicted the study’s findings. This study, the rigorous researchers said, was at most associational, not causal.
The promoters of the Seven Countries Study, however, said that lives were at stake. We can’t wait for “final scientific proof” (Taubes, p. 23). We must inform the public and have them change their diets. This attitude partnered with the ‘60s hostility to McDonalds and other high-fat fast food diets and culminated in the McGovern report of 1977 that made the litany virtually gospel. In the meantime, well-controlled experiments, right up to the present, continued and still continue to disconfirm the creed. Selection bias, the omission of anomalous data, is a term Taubes uses to help explain the championing of the litany.
In the course of his investigations, Taubes most importantly has liberated obese people from the tyranny of the “gluttony and sloth” argument. “You’re overweight because you eat too much and exercise too little.” Implication? Weakness of the will, bad character. Taubes and the more rigorous researchers? Clearly there is a genetic component to growing wide, just as there is a genetic component to growing tall. Causation indeed likely runs in the opposite direction. That is, we are not necessarily fat because we overeat and underexercise. Rather, we eat more because we are growing and become sedentary because we are fat.
The mechanism of obesity, writes Taubes (pp. 118-21), operates through the hormone insulin. The more carbohydrates we eat, the more insulin our bodies secrete, the more fat—for obese people, at any rate—is taken out of our bloodstream and stored in our fat cells. “Insulin,” as Taubes puts it, “works to make us fatter.”
Coercion in the public schools to make children eat “right” or less has become common, just as the European Union is now making sure children are not unduly exposed to those allegedly dangerous inflatables. Aside from the issue that governments have no right to tell us what or how much to eat, or how we should micromanage our children, how fallacy-proof is the scientific evidence that has led to these policies and near dogma about health and safety? How long before we’re all compelled to eat “right” or less?
Taubes has shown us how bad science can become a new consensus and lead to policy. I hope my attempt to condense his seven hundred pages into a few paragraphs is clear and correct. Why We Get Fat is only two hundred pages. I enthusiastically recommend that you read it. Taubes’ writing is sparklingly clear. His website is garytaubes.com.
# # #
This now completes five years of blogging. January 2012 begins the next five. Here are a couple of follow-ups on previous posts.
On Hitting . . . Dogs and Children. “With the popularity of The Dog Whisperer television show, books and products, the controversy over which methods are the most humane and effective ways to address behavior problems in dogs is dividing dog lovers all over the world.
“While animal behaviorists, trainers and other dog professionals recognize that the show is exposing dog owners to the possibility that their dogs’ behavior can be changed (and indeed, business is booming), the concern is that the show gives the false impression that behavior can be changed within a matter of hours and that the methods used are known to incite or increase aggressive behaviors.” Read more (1, 2).
Should Spanking Be a Felony? “Is it right or wrong to spank? It is not a question of right or wrong; in a way it is a case of cowardliness, for you are hitting someone not your own size. I don’t suppose you hit your husband when he is being a nuisance. Is it because you wouldn’t dare? He might strike you back. Of course, you’re perfectly safe hitting your child of three. She can’t strike you back.
“Spanking is an outlet for adult rage and frustration and hate. . . . Happy mothers do not spank . . .”
--A. S. Neill (pp. 99-100), Freedom—Not License!
Labels:
argument from uncertainty
,
coercion
,
diabetes
,
Gary Taubes
,
heart disease
,
McGovern
,
nutrition
,
obesity
,
selection bias
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)

Jerry Kirkpatrick's Blog by Jerry Kirkpatrick is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.