Showing posts with label writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label writing. Show all posts

Friday, January 17, 2025

On Writing

Writing is not automatic, and no one is born with the talent.
 
When I was a sophomore in a public high school, I was a student in an honors English class and earned gentlemanly A’s and B’s. For the next two years, I attended a private school.
 
In the first semester of my junior year, Miss K gave me a D- for not being able to write a coherent sentence. I was shocked and humiliated. Miss K said—apparently to make me feel better, and maybe it did—that I write like my brother (who had been a piano teacher at the school the year before). Perhaps this did make me feel better, though I do not recall reading much or any of my brother’s writing.
 
Miss K suggested that I enroll in her sophomore composition class during the second semester of my junior year, which I did.
 
Miss K was the first significant person who taught me how to write. She did it by insisting, “You can write anything to any length,” and she made us prove it, with six weekly assignments: (1) write three pages, (2) same topic, condense the three pages to three paragraphs, (3) condense the three paragraphs to one. New topic: (4) write one paragraph, (5) same topic, expand the one paragraph to three, (6) expand the three paragraphs to three pages.
 
As I recall, we went through two cycles of these six weekly assignments.
 
Writing at any length has never come easily to me, but the expansion part of these assignments was far easier than the condensations. To expand, one must add material, which usually requires more research.
 
Miss K taught us important condensation techniques. With my present knowledge of Ayn Rand’s theory of concepts, I would say that the essential technique is, well, essentialization. Miss K did not use those words.
 
She taught us that we must decide what to eliminate from the paper—whatever is not essential. I do not recall discussions of themes and topic sentences, though they are a place to begin. I believe Miss K assumed we knew about them from earlier grades. The next step is to reduce the several paragraphs to fewer sentences. This is accomplished by combining two or more sentences into connected independent clauses or sentences with one subordinate and one independent clause. If more condensation is required, begin by removing words from the sentences. Then change an independent clause into one that is subordinate. Reduce further by turning a subordinate clause into a prepositional phrase, then a prepositional phrase into an adjective or adverb. Finally, eliminate—if not essential to the condensed version of the work.
 
An important form of condensation writing is what used to be taught, unfortunately no longer, many decades ago, as précis writing. To learn it, I recommend finding a book from the 1930s or ‘40s, or even earlier. Here is one from 1913 by F. E. Robeson (9). Indeed, Robeson says, “The writer of a précis should constantly put himself in the position of a person who has not seen the original documents and yet wishes to have a clear knowledge of all that is essential in them.” His three requirements of the précis writer are to produce a “consecutive narrative” while including only what is important and excluding what is unimportant. An excellent example of précis writing is Ayn Rand’s chapter summaries (83–87) of her theory of concepts.
 
Another form of condensation writing is the law brief, which also requires essentialization but follows different rules than that of the précis. I did not attend law school, so will not comment on the brief.
 
The other significant influence on my ability to write (and to succeed in college as I thought of it) was Mrs. E in my senior year of high school. Mrs. E was my tutor to help me learn to write. The most important thing she said was, “What is it you are trying to say?” I cannot emphasize how important that question was for me. Many teachers and tutors will often take a look at what you have written, then say something like, “This is what you should say” or “This is how you should write it.” The teacher or tutor is now writing the paper, not you. And, I have to say, this is precisely what “peer reviewers” of academic papers do. As one journal editor said, “All of my reviewers want to recreate the papers in their own image” (Applying Principles, 130–32).
 
A tip I no longer recall where I found it, to overcome writer’s block, is to start writing anything . . . anything, such as, “I don’t know what to write” and write it over and over. If you are a student, add something like this: “This is a stupid assignment” and/or “This professor is an idiot!”
 
I have followed this advice a few times but have not gotten far before ideas begin coming to me. Keep an active mind during the process and let your subconscious percolate ideas, that is, filter and integrate the knowledge you have to generate possible themes. If nothing comes after a few (or many) lines, you may need to do more research. More research and more reading have worked miracles for me.
 
A question my younger colleagues would sometimes ask, surprising me, was, “You wrote a book! How did you do that?” My answer was that if you can write a paper—my colleagues were academics, so I am talking about academic papers—you can write a book. A book, I said, is a series of papers, connected by theme, transitions, and other appropriate editing. Students can think of long papers as a series of chunks, or thoughts, to be communicated.
 
Finally, do not let your initial thoughts and outline tell you the finished product must include all of those thoughts and must follow what is in the outline. When I first began drafting this post, the second and third paragraphs were the beginning, as one paragraph. I then thought, I need something else at the beginning, hence the one-line paragraph. Outlines for my books go through four or five often quite different iterations. And topics I initially thought were great insights (which itself in retrospect is questionable) never made it into the finished book. And, of course, I also have many “great insights” that never make it into my blogs.
 
A line attributed to various writers runs like this: “No one enjoys writing. Everyone enjoys having written.” I cannot say that I dislike writing, though I enjoy having written more. It is thanks especially to Miss K and Mrs. E for teaching me the techniques of writing. I think my enjoyment comes about by doing the research, thinking about how I might use this information in a book or blog, testing and trying various themes and organizations of the material.
 
Writing has been said to be like putting a puzzle together. I do not particularly like putting puzzles together, but the analogy applies. It is rewarding when the pieces fit.

 

Postscript. My experience in the private school, and its difference from the public, was not lost on me. I had already known about capitalism and the arguments for a free market in education. The rest of my courses in those two years, as well as my reading of Ayn Rand, also helped me survive college.

Wednesday, June 05, 2024

The Place of Emotions in Science

Thoughts underly our emotions. As psychologist Edith Packer (140) says, paraphrased, “When we are feeling something, we are thinking something.”
 
The opposite also is true—when we are thinking something, we are feeling something, which means we have emotions running through our minds whether we are aware of them or not.
 
Consciousness, to borrow a word from William James, is a stream, not separate compartments that can be shut off at will, though the evaluations that stand behind emotions can be repressed.
 
Scientists clearly have emotions, not just in their eureka moments of a major discovery, but in their typical workdays. Emotions are what motivate us.
 
When we acknowledge the presence of emotions in science, and scientists, we acknowledge that evaluations are present.  Behind every emotion the evaluation, as Packer argues, has two aspects, one universal that applies to all instances of a particular emotion, such as joy or anger, and one personal that includes all the concrete details of the moment when we have experienced the emotion.
 
Joy, for example, at the universal level means “I have achieved an important value.” Thus, “eureka”—or “I have found it,” the translation of the Greek—is a form of joy. The scientist’s personal evaluation—“all of my years of research have been worth it”—in the eureka moment might be expressed in behavior as energetic shouting and jumping up and down such that he almost knocks a beaker off the table. This would be a personal evaluation and experience that likely would last a long time in the scientist’s subconscious memories.*
 
It is this inner conversation or voice, as Packer describes personal evaluations, that constitute a key part of the content of our personal knowledge. Which means that knowledge, general or personal, is not “value-free” as the logical positivists for decades have insisted it must be.
 
Every emotion exhibits not just an evaluation, but also an action tendency, or urge to act. The scientist who, when young, is given a chemistry set for a birthday may later get excited in high school chemistry class and begin to think about a career in chemistry. Meeting and talking to professional chemists—a chemical engineer and a research chemist, for example—may help the young person solidify his or her career goals.
 
Going to work every day in an office or lab, after all, is motivated by our emotions of pleasure or pain we associate with the work.
 
Emotion is the driver of everything we do. Writers of both fact and fiction say they follow their emotions to come up with subjects, themes, and even the phrasing of sentences.  Many write “by ear,” more so than by the current rules of grammar and syntax.**
 
Whatever we have liked or disliked in our past, influences our present. Emotions contribute knowledge to our thought processes.  Those past emotions often are the sources of connections we make in the present, sometimes called creative insight, as well as guidance to follow particular lines of thought and experimentation.***
 
Repressed persons are also motivated by past emotions, though usually negative ones that they seek to avoid. Some who are repressed may appear in the present to experience no emotions.
 
A severely repressed scientist, for example, may exhibit a highly muted reaction to the eureka moment, such as a sober, unexpressive face and words that say, “This is good.” But the emotions, which means evaluations and values, are there at some level. Such a person is often desperately trying to avoid the error and appearance of the fallacy of the appeal to emotion.
 
Where does this fallacy come in to play? It is actually a simple notion that says it makes no sense to say or write, “It is true because I feel it.” This does not mean that we should not be motivated to become a scientist because of our emotions from the past or that we should not get excited over a eureka moment. It is indeed unfortunate that the repressed scientist does not jump up and down.
 
The point of the fallacy is that whatever emotions we have in the process of identifying a fact of reality, we must follow Aristotle’s laws of logic, especially the law of non-contradiction. Ayn Rand defines logic as “the art of non-contradictory identification.” Thus, in our work, we bring up our emotions to see if any of them are influencing our perceptions of reality.
 
If I am feeling that a leprechaun is on my desk instead of a glass of water, I assure you I am committing the fallacy. Or, consider the young man fired and jilted on the same day (in Individual Judgment and Introspection, 66–67); he feels that he will never find another job or lover. This is all the fallacy refers to, a feeling (in here) that contradicts the facts (out there).
 
Thus, scientists, I am quite certain, when coming up with a solution to a problem can, without guilt, go wild and crazy to celebrate!
 
 
* Another example: the universal evaluation of anger says, “An injustice has been done to me.” The personal evaluation would be the specific experiences of the moment when feeling anger at another person or institution.
 
** I have told students who could not come up with a term paper topic to “go with what grabs you,” meaning what your emotions are telling you. See this short essay on writing by ear and Ayn Rand (Kindle, 88): When writing, as opposed to editing, “you go by your emotions.”
 
*** For example, when researching my book Montessori, Dewey, and Capitalism, I was pleasantly surprised to find a connection between Maria Montessori, John Dewey, and Ayn Rand. They obviously do not agree with each other, but they nevertheless exhibit some similarities. See Linda Reardan, Emotions and Rational Values, chap. 4, for the fundamental explanation of how emotions contribute to thought.