Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Professors Good and Bad—Mostly Bad

In a 2010 blog post, published in Applying Principles, pp. 52–54, I express my surprise at how much I enjoyed working in business, as opposed to being a student. In my recently republished pamphlet “How to Survive Graduate School,” I give a bleak description of the academic world, especially for anyone pursuing a PhD degree. I acknowledge that exceptions exist, of course, but not in my experience. Below is a description of many of the professors I endured as a student in both undergraduate and graduate school.
 
I write this partly because I have encountered adults who say they enjoyed their college experiences (the academic part, not the extracurricular activities), including graduate school. I have always been surprised by these confessions, often leaving me to speculate about how serious such persons were about fundamental ideas, especially those who professed to be students of Ayn Rand. But I will give them the benefit of the doubt on the assumption that they went to better schools than I and had better professors.
 
First, what is a good professor? One who lectures—a rarity in many colleges today and certainly when I was a student. See my post, also from 2010, in Applying Principles, pp. 174–75, where I defend the lecture as essential aid in summarizing and clarifying the text, adding relevant material and examples to enhance the student’s understanding. Lectures, above all, must be relevant to the course description in the college catalogue, not lengthy digressions on, say, the Vietnam War, as they typically were in my day.
 
Historians (ancient and American) in undergraduate school and statisticians in graduate school were good professors who met the criteria I just specified. (Accountants also, but I only took one accounting class.) The best professor overall was Leonard Peikoff, from whom I took two philosophy courses in 1966 at the University of Denver. (See the preface to my latest book for more on that.) Professor Peikoff had the uncanny ability of throwing off one-liners that not just clearly illustrated a difficult concept in philosophy but were also funny. Young and naïve as I was, I naturally assumed that all of my subsequent philosophy professors would be just like him!
 
Not even close.
 
I did not declare my major as philosophy until my sophomore year. I had heard that a youngish graduate assistant had taken Dr. Peikoff’s graduate seminar the previous year on Objectivism’s theory of knowledge, so I chose him as my advisor. At our first and only meeting I asked him what he thought of the theory. He said that Ayn Rand’s use of measurement was “cute.” I don’t recall his subsequent words, but “simplistic” and “not profound” were most likely. For any future advice that I may have needed, I just read the college catalogue. I never had him for a class.
 
Only one philosophy professor was what I would call “good,” though not outstanding. She had studied under Brand Blanshard at Yale and taught the history of philosophy courses.
 
As for a “rogue’s gallery” of professors of philosophy and other subjects during my undergraduate years, here they are:

A freshly minted PhD from Yale in his course on ethics made a reference to Ayn Rand as “that broad with the 48-inch bust.” Message to me: don’t think of mentioning her name in his class. I didn’t.
 
In a course on Hobbes and Rousseau, I wrote a paper arguing that Rousseau was a collectivist. Obviously, said the professor, I did not understand Rousseau. B. Not an atypical grade for me when using Ayn Rand’s name in a paper.
 
I did get an A in the course on mathematical logic, though the only thing I remember about it is that it involved a lot of p’s and q’s. This, no doubt, prompted me to spend my spring vacation reading H. W. B. Joseph’s Introduction to Logic and just as promptly was ridiculed by the Hobbes and Rousseau professor for having wasted my free time on such an ancient and outmoded text.
 
In a course on the Philosophies of Democracy, the oldish, former chair never lectured, but conducted the class more like a dormitory bull session, i.e., a seminar. He also was concerned about being “cool” in the eyes of his young students—this was the late 1960s, after all. We read the anti-capitalists Franz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, and James Burnham, The Managerial Revolution.
 
Other subjects: The Cultural Anthropology professor, in a megasection of 160 students, spent the first ten minutes of a 50-minute class, going over his seating chart to mark down students who had not shown up. His exams were true-false questions, and not many, perhaps only ten or twenty.
 
The only thing I remember from the megasection of the Paul Samuelson Economics course is “guns or butter.” The professor kept saying we—meaning “society,” the collectivist “we”—have to decide whether we want more guns (this was the Vietnam era) or butter (consumable goods).
 
In a freshman English class, the assignment was to write an argumentative paper. So I summarized Ayn Rand’s epistemology. The professor was a freshly minted PhD from Princeton who, more than a couple of times, could not get his you-know-what out of bed in the morning to make it to his 8am class. After reading my paper, he said that it was the best paper he’d read written by a freshman—dot, dot, dot—“but I didn’t like it.” B. It apparently was not what he had in mind for argumentative writing.
 
Then there were the seminars. I took several. Dr. Peikoff, I was told, lectured in his seminar on the Objectivist epistemology. None of my professors did anything close to lecturing and I resented having to pay money to listen to other students talk. “Dormitory bull session” is an accurate description of seminars. In one philosophy seminar, the only thing I remember is that a classmate said the cockroach will be the only thing to survive a nuclear holocaust! (We did read Blanshard’s two-volume The Nature of Thought, which was well worth the read.)*

On to graduate school (Baruch College of the City University of New York): the teaching was worse: 

One professor stood up in front of class badly trying to reword the text and call it a lecture. Another on money and banking—well, I don’t remember a thing he said. After class, I would look at my notebook and find that I had nothing written down. 
 
Still another balanced his checkbook in the back of class while we were “working” in our groups, figuring out who was going to do what to piece together some kind of communal (collectivist) paper. The typist was the lucky one who did not have to do any research or reading!
 
On the second occasion when we were “working” in our groups, this same professor went home. After about a half hour, which we assumed was time enough for him to get home, the lights of New York City went out for the second time in history—the blackout of 1977, reminding me, of course, of Atlas Shrugged. The problem with this blackout is that we were in lower midtown Manhattan on the 19th floor of a building at 26th street and Park Avenue. I lived in Flushing, Queens. After getting about halfway to my apartment (walking, and hearing plate glass being broken behind me by looters), I spotted a cabbie who stopped to take me the rest of the way home. He didn’t want any money, but I paid him anyway. The character and generosity of New Yorkers usually comes out in situations like this.
 
Once in the doctoral program (beyond the MBA), the teaching continued to get worse. The finance professor put seven or eight books on the reading list, but told us not to buy any of them because he just put them there to get free copies from the publishers. (Business ethics anyone?) The course was all math based on perfect competition theory.
 
The professor of organizational behavior (formerly called industrial psychology or, sometimes, worker motivation and behavior) asserted at the beginning of class that the group is now the unit of analysis, not the individual.
 
Advanced micro- and macroeconomics classes were all math, based on perfect competition. A managerial economics class was all math and, of course, a forecasting class was all math. Foundations of Behavioral Research was all positivism, and quantitative.
 
There was a class on calculus and trigonometry required of all doctoral and MBA students. The professor was good, but he catered to the MBA students who could not remember their algebra. We never got to partial differentials.
 
There was one class that was quite good—on how to use the library! It was a zero-credit course, required of all doctoral students. Everyone tried to get out of the class, but no one ever did. The professor was a PhD in library science and gave us valuable information about the sources and functioning of libraries. The assignment was to write an annotated bibliography of a subject or author, based on the contents of the school’s library. I chose Ludwig von Mises. Quite a few of his books were in the library.
 
Then, there was the advanced consumer behavior research class that was actually a course on multivariate statistics. The professor did nothing. We all had to prepare and make presentations. When I was doing mine on canonical correlation, the professor nodded off. I was tempted to slam a textbook on the floor or a desk, but, probably wisely, chose not to. The professor’s reputation preceded my attendance in the course; I did not want to take his class, but could not avoid it. I learned next to nothing.
 
A finance professor did discuss capital budgeting in class, but also said that he was not going to discuss six or eight chapters of the text that were to be on the exam. I accumulated about twenty pages of notes on those chapters, condensed them initially to about eight or ten pages, then finally to three, which became my study notes. The process was one of essentialization, which enabled me to retain an enormous amount of material. I aced the exam. I did not appreciate the professor’s abandonment of teaching responsibility.
I chronicle more in my “How to Survive Graduate School” pamphlet, including especially my adventures with committees. The most curious one was what was called a “position paper,” the one in which a professor on the committee, said, as I write in the pamphlet, “Marxists are so badly discriminated against in this country.”
 
This professor, who received his PhD from New York University when Mises was there, made a derogatory comment about “those people who wanted to study with that von Hague fellow.” Yes, “Hague.” I think he was thinking of Hayek, but did not know that it was Mises who was at NYU, not Hayek.
 
I say “curious” about the position paper because I had already written a master’s thesis. I suspect it was put in the curriculum for doctoral students who bypass the MBA and go straight to the PhD. Someone on that committee said that my paper was not really a position paper. I had presented three schools of economic thought—neoclassical, Chicago, and Austrian—and what their theories had to say about marketing, taking my stand, or position, with the Austrians. Much of this paper ended up in my book In Defense of Advertising.
 
I think the position paper was supposed to be, in good positivist fashion, a review of a few dozen statistical studies and my concluding judgment of how the studies had “advanced” science.
 
The committee, without putting it into words, convinced me that my subsequent book on the defense of advertising would never fly as a PhD dissertation.
 
So much for my rant about professors. I don’t know if I would survive in today’s academic climate. Politicization is everywhere. Censorship, punishment, and firings for saying and writing the wrong thing are rampant.
 
It would probably drive me to seek a job as an electrician—and make upwards of $200,000 a year!
 
Why is academia so bad and unresponsive to its paying customers? I answered that question in Montessori, Dewey, and Capitalism, chapter 5, especially the section on bureaucratic education. Schools, all schools, including the universities, are bureaus of the government.
 
Hey profs—I want my money back!
 
 
* I think the model of a good seminar is that of the professional musician’s master class given to a number of students of a particular music teacher. Each student performs a short piece or study. The master then critiques and recommends solutions to problems, to improve the student’s technique and expression of the music. The Ludwig von Mises seminar at New York University, so I’ve heard and read about, began with Mises, the master, talking about some issue for about 30 minutes or so, followed by questions from the group with Mises analyzing and answering the questions. Often, a student would read a paper, followed by the master discussing what was presented. Only once was I present at a master music class (as observer, not student) and never did I experience a master teacher in a seminar.
 

Friday, October 07, 2011

There Are More Important Things in Life Than Softball

The impetus for this post is once again my daughter’s softball. She is currently playing in what is called “travel,” as opposed to “recreational,” ball and the seemingly endless string of practices and games almost every weekend tempt me to recite the title of this post to other parents.

Not that I want to take anything away from my daughter’s talent and desire to excel in a fun sport, nor the same of the other parents’ daughters, but a sense of perspective may be in order, especially considering the low odds of winning an athletic scholarship to college, the risks of injury (1, 2, 3) and burnout before even getting to that point, and the studies that now show multiple sports experiences and deliberate (unorganized) play develop better perception and decision making than the single, year-round specialization many young athletes today endure.

Sports, of course, are not the only activity of youth in which a nearly 24/7 pressure-cooker atmosphere exists. Music, dance, and drama teachers, and the children’s parents, not to mention the academic teachers, can also lay it on thick; the term “stage mom” (1, 2) that comes to us from the theatre keeps coming to mind.

Part of the obsession many coaches, teachers, and parents have about sports, or the arts and academics, stems from a misunderstanding of the differences between the less accomplished and the more accomplished, or between “amateur” and “professional.”


By “professional” here I mean only a greater degree of skill and dedication, not “paid professional,” though the young persons may be aiming for professional careers in sports or the arts or science and the coaches and teachers may be grooming them for that goal. In softball the difference is between “recreational” and “travel” ball and in the arts it may be the difference between performing in the local community and attending a select arts high school.

The assumed differences between these two levels, as stated by one youth baseball organization, include the possibility of failure and rejection in travel ball, but not in recreational; the alleged life lesson to sacrifice leisure to hard work so success will follow; and the supposed lack of need for instruction at this “nearly professional” level. There are kernels of truth in all three of these differences, but these kernels get distorted when coaches, teachers, and parents lose perspective, forgetting about the whole of life.

Take the difference about the possibility of failure. Even at a lower level of skill, such as in a marching band or softball, not everyone participates one-hundred percent of the time. Only some band members may perform in the pep band at basketball games and even fewer in the swing band. Soloists at the spring concert may be fewer than a handful. The same is true for softball; not everyone can be pitcher.


More important, not achieving an initial goal need not be viewed as failure. A clarinetist, for example, who transfers from a small-town marching band to an arts high school orchestra may not earn one of the top four positions in the orchestra. This eye-opening awareness of the greater skill of others should be experienced as motivator, not a threat to success or happiness. There is no more important attitude to cultivate than seeing others’ achievements as an inspiration.

To say that youth should sacrifice leisure to hard work so success will follow is misleading, especially if it is presented as “we expect you to give up your vacation” for the sake of softball, or music, etc. Paid professionals do not do this, except on occasion, mainly because they know their schedules well in advance. The problem with youth sports is that communication, advance or otherwise, is often lacking, leading to surprises in the schedule.


Hard work, yes; and all children who enjoy an activity, whether it be sports, the arts, or a business or science club will, if not hampered by authoritarian adults, devote long hours of concentrated attention to improving their knowledge and skill. This concentrated attention is sometimes, unfortunately, interpreted by adults as “sacrifice” in the sense of giving up a higher value for the sake of a lower one. “Dedication” and “self-motivation” would be better descriptors.

The notion that higher levels of skill do not need instruction stems from the term “director,” such as the director of a play or conductor of an orchestra. Some coaches claim the same prerogative for their advanced teams. But direction means guiding the skills of others to produce the effect the director envisions.


That in itself is teaching, and all directors, including conductors and coaches, provide a variety of instructions to their performers to accomplish what they want. That coaches at the highest level of professional sports are teachers became obvious during the 1987 National Football League strike when secondary players were hired as substitutes to play games while the stars were walking picket lines. Much commentary was made about the expert teaching abilities of various coaches.

When a coach, or conductor or director, says that he or she assumes a certain skill level and is not there to teach, I would beware that blind obedience is what is wanted, as in “I expect you to have the discipline to do what I say.” “Discipline,” however, means acting in accordance with one’s own self-imposed guidelines. It is the mark of an advanced skill. Even at an advanced level, coaches, teachers, and conductors should aim to help turn caterpillars into butterflies.

Total commitment at the expense of everything else—spending every weekend and a few week nights on one’s sport or art, because “that’s the way we do it here” or because “that’s the only way to get a scholarship”—is obsession of the stage parent type. When the commitment does not originate in the child, injury or burnout or even parental estrangement can result. Perspective on why an activity is being pursued needs always to be kept in the forefront of parents’ minds.

Monday, June 21, 2010

Rankism and the Well-Earned Disrespect of Some Teachers

In the ancient world, teachers were not respected. “He’s either dead or else he’s teaching somewhere” was a comment made in a comedy fragment about someone missing from a gathering. And Lucian relegated a dethroned king to Hades to sell salt or old boots . . . or to become a teacher.* Making money on the market—teachers were paid a fee for their services—was disparaged. Not until the Judeo-Christian influence did teachers begin to gain respect.

Today, teachers are admired, not just for the service they provide to educate the young, but for their seemingly tireless dedication to long hours of preparation and their equally seemingly tireless patience to answer repetitive questions. Unfortunately, not all teachers return the admiration to their students, colleagues, and administrative assistants, which leads to sniping complaints from outsiders about privilege and long vacations.

The root of this lack of respect is what former Oberlin College president, Robert Fuller, calls rankism or the abuse of rank (1, 2). The disrespect is deserved, for the rankism manifests itself as expressions of power over and taking advantage of those not at the same level of authority. For example, a professor may write an email explaining why an administrative assistant should drop everything and copy his receipts from a recent academic trip. The assistant works for the chair of the department, not the individual faculty, but the professor goes to great length to explain why his time is more valuable than the assistant’s—not in the least noticing that in the time it took him to compose and edit the email he could have copied his own receipts. Such manual labor, apparently, is beneath his dignity, but not that of the “lowly” administrative assistant.

Other forms of condescension by senior faculty include failing so much as to say hello to a part-time instructor or interrupting without apology a conversation between a part-time instructor and the chair of the department, with the part-timer seeing nothing but the interrupter’s back. Political power play is how some might cynically or even approvingly describe the senior professor’s behavior. Childish disingenuousness might be another description. Or the behavior might be characterized as the desperate quest for approval of a defensively frail ego because, as I have written before, the stakes in the academic world are so small.

Rankism toward students is legion. In the absence of corporal punishment, verbal abuse has become the tool of putting students in their places. An “appalling lack of civility” is how Charles Silberman in 1970 described the contempt that teachers and principals exhibit toward their students. Sarcasm, ridicule, and just plain rudeness seem to be the preferred means of pulling rank today, such as sternly telling a ten-year-old that she is still a child until the age of eighteen. This ignores and devalues the intelligence of the ten-year-old who knows well that one does not automatically become an adult by celebrating a birthday; it also ignores and devalues the maturity of the ten-year-old who considers a child to be younger than six. The effect of the rudeness is to deflate developing self-esteem and silence opposition or disagreement.

One of the worst forms of rankism that a teacher can pull is to talk in class negatively about others who are not present to defend themselves. Such behavior is beyond rude and childish. It is unethical. It certainly is none of the students’ business what the teacher thinks about other students, teachers, or administrative assistants. But such behavior does happen in the cocoon-tenured environment of the academic world. The teacher will not be fired, but the students and administrative assistants who are talked about may be harmed. Sometimes, unfortunately, that is even the intent of the negative talk.

Fuller’s campaign against rankism is to establish a new meaning of equality. It does not mean, he says, equality of ability, knowledge, intelligence, or position or rank. It means equality of dignity. It means treating others, regardless of age or rank (or race, gender, nationality, etc.), as human beings. In the military world, a soldier’s general is a commander who treats those under him with care and kindness. A player’s coach exhibits the same toward his athletes. Kindness and respect are what those in authority need to exude toward those in a lower rank. It means being nice.

*Cited in H. I. Marrou, A History of Education in Antiquity, part two, chapter  5.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Teaching versus Learning versus Doing

Much ink has been spilled for decades over the concepts of teaching, learning, and doing, producing such commonplaces as “learning by doing is the best way to learn” and “let’s focus on learning, not teaching.” A couple of clarifications, however, need to be made about both of these remarks.

Consider the first one. Learning and doing, epistemologically and psychologically, are two different mental processes. They never occur precisely at the same time. Learning is the acquisition of knowledge, doing is application. Acquisition is generalization, application is deduction from the general to employ the deduction in a specific concrete situation. A child learns the generalization of balance, of shifting one’s weight, when riding a bicycle. The child applies that knowledge in practice to perfect the skill. Learning comes before doing, perhaps from a parent or older sibling who is teaching the concept of balance or through trial-and-error learning. Sometimes it might occur a split second before the doing but it still comes before.

Trial-and-error learning proceeds in this manner. Try one thing. It doesn’t work. Try something else. It doesn’t work. But there may be similarities in the two actions that did not work sufficient to make a primitive generalization. Deduction from the generalization then follows to try a new action. It doesn’t work perfectly, but it works better than the previous failures. More trial, error, generalization, deduction, and further trial then ensue. Some learners are quick to pick up through observation what has to be done to execute a new skill; others are not. The point, however, is that ideas—no matter how primitive or unformed, or even how unaware the actor may be of the ideas—precede action. Add to this that ingrained mental and/or physical habits may have to be challenged and changed before the skill can be developed.

The significance of teaching before doing is to save the time that can be wasted when going through repeated efforts of trial and error. It also may prevent injury that can result from uninformed trial and error, such as, without instruction, learning to ride a bicycle or operate a complicated piece of machinery. “Learn-by-doing”—when understood to mean practice—is essential to perfecting a skill, mental or physical, but mental understanding, even of a mental skill like logical thinking, comes first.

This takes us to the comment about focusing on learning, not teaching. To teach, however, means to effect learning, to see to it that the students understand and can apply what has been taught. Even the standard definition of teaching—the transfer of knowledge from one person to another—indicates that teaching is not achieved until learning has been accomplished.

Some of the desire, no doubt, to emphasize learning over teaching comes from distrust of the lecture as a legitimate teaching method, but a well crafted lecture framed in essentials and delivered with conviction can effect a great deal of learning in its listeners. More generally, the comment most likely stems from the tired indifference to teaching and learning, not to mention overt rudeness, exhibited by many tenured teachers and professors. The state-run school and university systems do not cater to the needs and wants of their customers. Yet that is precisely what the focus on learning means.

In marketing—and teachers, as I have written before, are sales reps—a notion called the “marketing concept” says that everyone in the company, from the president to the stock boy, should not make any decision or take any action without first considering its effects on the customer. “We are no longer in the business of selling what we make,” General Electric said many years ago, “but making only what we can sell.” This means, quite simply, whether one is a writer, a teacher, or a sales rep: “know thy audience.” Know where the students are now in the learning process, then challenge them by stretching. But the stretching cannot go too far because that produces discouragement and it cannot be too elementary because that creates boredom. Finding the middle ground is what teaching to effect learning is all about. It is not an easy task. It requires constant observation of the students and adaptation to the their needs.

Focusing on learning is what every good teacher should routinely do. Teaching and learning are separate activities, performed by different people. The teacher teaches, the learner learns. But the teacher knows what and how to teach by first tuning into the learner. Anything else is whistling in the wind.